Extract:
A New Use for Acupuncture
Over the years, acupuncture has become a more widely accepted type of alternative medicine. It is used for a wide variety of ailments, and if a recent study from Germany is valid, relieving menstrual pain can be added to the continuously growing list.
Traditionally nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are the typical treatment for menstrual discomfort. However, as many consumers and physicians are aware, NSAIDs have a number of side effects, including nausea, vomiting, rash, dizziness, headache, and drowsiness. Acupuncture rarely has any kind of side effects other than the occasional stinging sensation when the needle is inserted or a deep ache around it after it is in place.
Acupuncture has proven helpful with relieving a number of kinds of pain, so researchers at Charité University Medical Center in Berlin wanted to find out how effective it might be in combating cramps and other menstrual discomforts. More than 200 women were enrolled in the study, and after three months and approximately 10 sessions, the women who were treated with acupuncture reported significantly less pain than those in the control group who received no treatment at all. They also reported a 33 percent improvement in their symptoms. Because of these findings, the researchers came to the conclusion that “acupuncture should be considered as a viable option in the management of these patients.”
Identify the overall tone of the essay.
-
A
Cautionary
-
B
Unconvinced
-
C
Optimistic
-
D
Insensitive
The overall tone is optimistic, emphasizing acupuncture's promising results and minimal risks without skepticism or cautionary overemphasis.
A) Cautionary
Caution would emphasize risks or limitations. While acupuncture's "occasional stinging" is mentioned, it's framed as minor compared to NSAID side effects, with overall emphasis on positive outcomes and researcher endorsement.
B) Unconvinced
Unconvinced would express doubt about efficacy. The passage presents clear positive results ("significantly less pain," "33 percent improvement") and researcher endorsement without skeptical qualifiers.
C) Optimistic
Optimism permeates the passage through: framing acupuncture as expanding treatment options ("continuously growing list"), contrasting its minimal side effects favorably against NSAIDs' extensive problems, highlighting significant pain reduction results, and concluding with researcher endorsement as "viable option", creating consistently positive outlook.
D) Insensitive
Insensitive would disregard patient concerns. The passage acknowledges pain relief needs and treatment side effect burdens, demonstrating patient-centered awareness rather than insensitivity.
Conclusion
Tone analysis requires evaluating dominant emotional quality across an entire passage. The consistent emphasis on acupuncture's benefits, favorable risk profile, and researcher endorsement, without skeptical qualifiers or risk overemphasis, creates an overall optimistic rather than cautionary, doubtful, or insensitive tone.