In response to a students question regarding choosing a psychiatric specialty, a charge nurse states, Mentally ill clients need special care. If I were in that position, Id want a caring nurse also. From which ethical framework is the charge nurse operating?

Question

In response to a students question regarding choosing a psychiatric specialty, a charge nurse states, Mentally ill clients need special care. If I were in that position, Id want a caring nurse also. From which ethical framework is the charge nurse operating??  
A. Kantianism  
B. Christian ethics  
C. Ethical egoism  
D. Utilitarianism

NursesPath · Accepted Answer

Correct Answer: (B)Christian ethics. 
Rationale: The interpretation supported by the scenario is Christian ethics.A. KantianismThis reflects a related idea, but it fits best when the idea in “Kantianism” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.B. Christian ethicsThis aligns with the concept that The charge nurse is operating from a Christian ethics framework. A basic principle in Christian ethics is to do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Kantianism states that decisions should be based on moral law and that actions are bound by a sense of moral duty. Utilitarianism holds that decisions should be made with a focus on the end result being happiness. Ethical egoism promotes the idea that what is right is good for the individual. Environment The underlying principle in the stem is best addressed by choosing the response that is both specific to the cue provided and consistent with evidence-informed psychiatric nursing practice. From a nursing standpoint, this selection guides assessment and interventions toward what is most clinically meaningful in the moment—risk reduction, safety, accurate appraisal, and support for adaptive coping.C. Ethical egoismThis would apply in a different scenario where the idea in “Ethical egoism” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.D. UtilitarianismThis could seem tempting if the idea in “Utilitarianism” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.ConclusionThe scenario is best handled by identifying what the nurse must interpret or prioritize first and then choosing the statement that fits that requirement with the least distortion. The distractors have surface appeal, but they do not align as tightly with the clinical cue embedded in the stem.

In response to a students question regarding choosing a psychiatric specialty, a charge nurse states, Mentally ill clients need special care. If I were in that position, Id want a caring nurse also. From which ethical framework is the charge nurse operating?

A
Kantianism

B
Christian ethics

C
Ethical egoism

D
Utilitarianism

The interpretation supported by the scenario is Christian ethics.

Related Questions

In response to a students question regarding choosing a psychiatric specialty, a charge nurse states, Mentally ill clients need special care. If I were in that position, Id want a caring nurse also. From which ethical framework is the charge nurse operating?

A Kantianism B Christian ethics C Ethical egoism D Utilitarianism

The interpretation supported by the scenario is Christian ethics.

Related Questions

A
Kantianism

B
Christian ethics

C
Ethical egoism

D
Utilitarianism